However, once I selected my new desktop image I noticed a problem. See the majestic trees on the left monitor? They're supposed to be on the far right of the right monitor, which is also the main display monitor. This is certainly a problem.
I knew that my monitor-spanning image's 'Picture position' had to be set to tile in 'Control Panel\Appearance and Personalization\Personalization\Desktop Background' so I did some searching using terms such as 'tiling wrong way' and tiling 'right to left' and eventually came across a post like this one that revealed the underlying issue: Windows starts drawing the image in the top left of the primary display then wraps to the other displays.
With this knowledge I realized that I was going to have to use Paint.Net to resolve the matter.
The first step was to break up my 3840 x 1080 image into two equal distinct images. Following these steps from the Paint.Net forum I was able to produce two 1920 x 1080 images.
- Open original source image
- Click on Image > Canvas Size
- Uncheck Maintain aspect ratio CheckBox
- Set pixel size to 1920 width, leaving height as is
- Set Anchor to Top Left
- Save this half of the photo, naming 'left', '1', or whatever you choose
- Click undo, to undo the canvas size and repeat for the right half or reopening the source image and repeat, using 'Top Right' for step 5
- Open the image that you want to appear on the left monitor first
- Image > Canvas Size
- Uncheck Maintain aspect ratio CheckBox
- Set Anchor to Top Right
- Double the width (in my case I changed 1920 to 3840)
- Import the image that you want to appear on the right monitor by using Layers > Import From File (by default this image's anchor is top left
- Save this new file
Yes.
Clearly this solution is not applicable to all monitor configurations, but it should give you an idea of how to solve this problem.